I pride myself in being outrageously frugal and outrageously into data (thank you to my years of being broke while getting my PhD). So instead of a Spotify Wrapped, I’m doing a Sephora Rouge Wrapped. Here’s everything I purchased in 2025 to reach Sephora Rouge.
Spoiler: I spent roughly $800 and was able to get about $1400 worth of items. And hit Sephora Rouge, which is after $1000 of spend.
Let’s get into the math… Below, you’ll find my spreadsheet of every single item I purchased, the price of the item (minus sales tax, as Sephora does not count tax as part of the Rouge calculation), and how many I purchased. It totaled to $1030 spent (without sales tax in it), just hitting Rouge for the year.
“⚡ TL;DR: The 2025 Rouge Strategy
The Goal: Hit Sephora Rouge ($1,000 spend) for the lowest out-of-pocket cost.
The Result: I got $1,384 worth of product for an effective cost of $794.
How it Works:
1. Stack the Savings: Buy during 20% off sales (Spring/Fall).
2. FSA/HSA “Discount”: I spent $556 on FSA-eligible items (Sunscreen/Sanitizer). Using pre-tax dollars saved me ~$236 in income tax.
3. The “Anchor” Items: High-spend items like Touchland sets and Summer Fridays SPF count 100% toward Rouge but are 100% reimbursable via FSA.”
How I Reached the $1,000 Rouge Threshold with $794.06 in "Real" Money
If you’ve read any of my articles before, you’ll be highly familiar with my love for FSA/HSA accounts. They allow you to use pre-tax dollars towards medical purchases. In the case of Sephora, the medical purchases would be sunscreen, hand sanitizer, and acne products.
But how did $800 get me to $1000 in Sephora’s Beauty Insider Program?
I prioritized FSA-eligible items
Looking at my individual line items, I can total up how many of these products are FSA-eligible.
For 2025, I bought $556.80 (sales tax not included) of FSA-eligible items. That leaves $473.90 as non-FSA-eligible purchases.
For my specific income tax bracket (estimate), I would expect a 42.5% tax rate. That would mean for the $556.80 I spent, I saved 42.5% of that (or $236.64).
So taking the total I spent ($1030.70) and subtracting out the income tax that I didn’t have to pay ($236.64), I arrive at the amount I spent for 2025: $794.06.
Possible optimization
If I wanted to go the extra mile, I would have increased my proportion of FSA-eligible items, relative to non-FSA-eligible items. If I purchased truly $1030.70 of only FSA-eligible items, my income tax savings would have been almost double: $438. That would mean my total amount “spent” would be $562, or almost half of what you actually need to spend to reach Sephora Rouge.
But that’s not entirely possible, especially if you have specific products you like. Or you use specific products that do not have SPF versions available. And I would not blame you because I feel strongly about my setting sprays (and am a loyalist to Milk Makeup and Charlotte Tilbury). The Supergoop! one makes my eyes run like no other, so I always stick to non-SPF setting sprays.
How to use FSA
When purchasing your FSA-eligible products at Sephora, you have to check out with your normal credit card. They do not (yet) take FSA card providers. After your transaction, you submit it to your FSA benefits provider for reimbursement. There, they’ll send you a check for the amount you paid for your sunscreen, hand sanitizer, or acne products (including the sales tax).
For more information, check out my blogs to troubleshoot rejected FSA claims or to submit them entirely.
Stacking FSA with Sephora Discounts
Another thing that helped me maximize my overall value relative to how much I spent was waiting for Sephora Sales to be the time when I purchased a lot of my FSA-eligible items. The additional 20% (or more, depending on the product) will help you get more value out of the product. Combining that with your FSA “pre-tax savings,” you’re looking at getting the products for almost 50% off.
Dollars spent
And because your FSA is a use-it-or-lose-it situation each year, it always is important to check your balance at the end of the year. Or my favorite time to look at those balances is in October, as the Sephora Savings Event in the fall is typically late October. And they also usually do an extra (one-time use) 20% off sale in December in case you have more FSA-eligible purchases you want to make.
The biggest thing to keep in mind is that your FSA benefits provider has the ability to reject your claim if it looks like you are stockpiling. That’s essentially if you are buying more product at once than you would use by the end of the year. Since FSA accounts are meant to be used in the same year that they are created, you are technically not supposed to be using the products in years to come, even if you purchased them during the correct year. So please be mindful about your purchase timings when it comes to "stocking up.”
So spread your FSA purchases our during the Spring and Fall Sephora Savings Events.
Fun Data Analyses of My Expenditures
# Products purchased at discount
Items per category
Sephora Rouge Starter Kit:
If you’re looking to maximize your dollars and still hit Rouge next year, here’s some products I would recommend:
Touchland Top Favorites Hand Sanitizer: The set is already discounted, meaning any sale that stacks on top of it will be an even better deal. And let’s face it, these hand sanitizers are already crazy expensive. So I’ll take any savings I can get.
Summer Fridays ShadeDrops SPF30: These are a very friendly mineral sunscreen that works across a variety of skin tones.
Caudalie Vinosun SPF50: These are basically a copy and paste of the Summer Fridays ones, except they are more expensive and have a higher sun protection.
Ciele: There are so many good makeup/color cosmetic products from Ciele. You’ll pretty much be able to transition your entire makeup routine over to them if you wanted to (minus the setting spray).
And if you don’t like Ciele all that much, Supergoop! also has a very extensive list of makeup-type products that have sun protection in them too.
I’ve also got a blog of lots of FSA-eligible products so you can purchase to your heart’s desire!
Hopefully this post inspired you to hit Sephora Rouge next year more cost effectively! Because there are lots of benefits you can get from it.
Thanks for reading!
Note: this post may contain affiliate links, which do not cost you anything but they help keep the blog running.